MYPolygyny.com
Knowledge for the Muslim household
Flashcards Lineage

Q&A › Conflict & resolution

🕊️ Conflict & resolution · #11

What does 'separate from them in bed' mean, and for how long is it permitted?

Hajr in an-Nisa' 4:34 means the husband not sleeping with his wife, or turning away from her in bed, as a sign of displeasure, in the hope that she will reconcile.
It is done inside the home, not by leaving the wife outside or shaming her in front of others; the Prophet ﷺ advised "do not shun her except within the house" (narrated by Abu Dawud, hasan sahih). The texts set no fixed period; scholars say it should last only as long as needed to have an effect. The Prophet ﷺ once kept away from his wives for a month. Shafi'i scholars distinguish: separating beds is permitted for the purpose of correction, but not speaking for more than three days is forbidden. It is not a tool for punishment or torment. See Nushuz & conflict.

Sources

Surah an-Nisa' 4:34narrated by Abu Dawud (hasan sahih)Sahih Muslim, Kitab al-Birr wa as-Silah wa al-Adab
← PreviousWhat is an Interim Protection Order (IPO) and how do I apply for one?Next →Is it sinful for husband and wife not to speak for days after a quarrel?

Related questions

Betulkah Islam benarkan suami pukul isteri? Apa maksud sebenar an-Nisa' 4:34?Tidak — Islam tidak membenarkan suami mencederakan, menyakiti atau mendera isteri; ayat 4:34 diletakkan dengan had yang …Apa maksud nusyuz isteri dalam Islam?Nusyuz isteri bermaksud isteri keluar daripada ketaatan yang wajib kepada suami dalam perkara makruf tanpa alasan syarie…Apa maksud syiqaq dalam undang-undang keluarga Islam?Syiqaq ialah perselisihan yang berpanjangan dan serius antara suami isteri sehingga sukar hidup bersama, dan ia istilah …Suami mengambil gaji saya dan mengawal semua wang sehingga saya tidak ada duit sendiri. Adakah ini dibenarkan?Tidak. Gaji dan harta isteri miliknya sendiri, dan mengambilnya tanpa kerelaan atau menyekat isteri daripada menggunakan…Kami bercadang berpisah rumah buat sementara untuk bertenang. Adakah ini dibenarkan dan apa kesannya?Dibenarkan jika dipersetujui bersama dan bertujuan memperbaiki, bukan menggantung isteri tanpa kepastian; tetapkan tempo…Kami kerap bertengkar (tanpa pukulan) di hadapan anak-anak. Apakah kesannya kepada mereka?Anak yang kerap menyaksikan ibu bapa bertengkar hebat boleh menjadi cemas, murung atau menyalahkan diri sendiri, walaupu…
This answer is general reference, not a fatwa. For your situation, consult the religious affairs office, a Syarie lawyer or your state Syariah Court.

Comments or feedback

Read only by the MYPolygyny administrator — never published.

🔒 Do not include sensitive personal details. Privacy notice

About Us · Ask · Site Map · Privacy · Editorial policy · Disclaimer

✓ Pemindahan pelayan selesai — kini lebih bersedia untuk berkhidmat kepada anda. · Server migration completed — ready to serve you better from now on.